Eddie’s Sweet Shop Placed on Historic Business Preservation Registry
Views: 117

Vito Citrano & his father Giuseppe Citrano, Photo courtesy of the Citrano family.
BY MICHAEL PERLMAN
mperlman@queensledger.com
Forest Hills is known for tennis, music, an earliest planned garden community; Forest Hills Gardens, and of course ice cream! Eddie’s Sweet Shop at 105-29 Metropolitan Avenue holds the record for the most intact and likely the longest continuously operating ice cream parlor citywide.
On September 24, the historic ice cream parlor was the recipient of a certificate which read, “Eddie’s Sweet Shop in Forest Hills, New York has been designated a historic business in the State of New York and has been added to the Historic Business Preservation Registry by the office of Parks, Recreation & Historic Preservation.” It was signed by Commissioner Kathy Moser and Senator Joseph P. Addabbo, Jr. of the 15th Senate District.
It was a crowning moment for owner Vito Citrano and his wife Angelina Citrano, as well as his father Giuseppe (Joe) Citrano. “It’s our honor that Eddie’s Sweet Shop was designated through the Historic Business Preservation Registry. We are so proud since it is a continuous legacy to this old-fashioned ice cream parlor for all to enjoy,” said Vito and Angelina.
“It was so wonderful having Senator Addabbo Jr. come to our shop to present us with such a prestigious honor,” said Vito. “What an amazing and happy afternoon it was for our family. The senator arrived before we opened our store to the public, so it was a beautiful private presentation,” continued Angelina.
They plan to display their certificate in a recognizable spot for everyone, ranging from devoted local patrons to tourists. This display will also spark memories for the Citrano family and their dedicated staff about how fortunate they are to achieve this milestone. The couple explained, “Our new customers would also love to know about our achievement, since as you step into our store, it becomes a step back in time, and this certificate proves it. You feel like you’re somewhere so special, enjoying something amazing that we prepare on premises for all these years.”
According to city records, 105-29 Metropolitan Avenue had a New Building application filed on June 24, 1925 for a two-story brick building, consisting of shops on the first story and dwellings on the second. A Certificate of Occupancy was issued on September 10, 1925 to J. Rosenberg. Seelig & Finkelstein of 44 Court Street in Brooklyn drafted blueprints, and Isidore Solomon would be the owner. Nevertheless, the earliest business records are yet to be seen. Rumor has it that an ice cream bakery with a lunch counter existed at the site.

The historic facade with a recently restored neon sign, Photo by Angelina Citrano.
Around 1949, the spot was named Witt’s Ice Cream Parlor after owner William Witt. Ads read “Our Own Make,” referring to ice cream and candy. Patrons would call BO 8-9794. When he retired to Florida in 1967, the shop was sold to the Citrano family, who renamed the historic spot Eddie’s Sweet Shop in 1968. At the time, Vito was only a year old. He began lending a helping hand during his childhood, but did not get paid until age 12. Giuseppe and his son Vito Citrano of Forest Hills coined the slogans, “Take your children to the place your grandparents had ice cream” and “A Forest Hills tradition for four generations.” Three generations worked alongside one another until Vito’s grandpa, also Vito, passed away in September 1995.
On July 20, 1979, a time when classic ice cream parlors were already an endangered species, Ann Barry of The New York Times wrote “Where To Find The Best Ice Cream Treats in Town.” She conducted a survey on the basis of ambiance and quality ingredients, and artist Randy Jones sketched “The Great Ice Cream Safari” comic strip. It featured an elephant hopping into classic and more modern parlors. The elephant saved Eddie’s Sweet Shop for last, where a patron on a swivel stool stated, “This antique parlor would make a fine trophy in the Smithsonian!”
The landmark Metropolitan Avenue corner features authentic brickwork and signs reading “Eddie’s Sweet Shop” and “Ice Cream” with Coca-Cola insignias. The uppermost window panes feature leaded glass reading “Candy” and “Ice Cream.” Leaded glass interior panes depict a sunburst motif with tulips.
The interior evokes the turn of the 19th century, which is dominated by a honeycomb pattern inlaid mosaic floor and a stamped tin ceiling with rose-accented molding. Patrons come upon an elegantly paned mahogany and marble counter with cast-iron swivel stools, where they sit elbow to elbow facing friendly soda jerkers. The timeless backdrop of an ornate wooden built-in features two arched inlaid mirrors and 3 varied arched pediments enhanced by stenciled floral gold leaf designs with a hint of red and green. An antique register was manufactured by The National Cash Register Co. of Dayton, Ohio. Also of great significance is one of the first electric Frigidaire freezers. Authentic tapestry-appointed woodwork and candlestick fixtures surround the back seating area. The woodwork is crowned by a wall clock produced by the pioneer Seth Thomas Clock Company, which also manufactured the Grand Central Station clock. Another treat is a classic wood phone booth.
Reflecting on how the beloved ice cream parlor withstood the test of time, the Citrano family had much to share. “We feel so happy to see that Eddie’s Sweet Shop served generations of customers through the years we have been here, as well as new ones. Our family estimates that over 30 films, commercials, and ads have been produced at our shop during the years we own it.Eddie’s Sweet Shop hosts a cinematic chapter with scenes from “Brighton Beach Memoirs” as well as “Remember Me.” Some televised commercials included Hostess, Coke, Pepsi, and Louis Sherry Ice Cream.
Vito said, “My father showed me not to be afraid to work hard. When it’s time to make hot fudge, I will keep stirring until it’s right, no matter how late it is or tired I am.” Angelina is also grateful. “We had many proposals at Eddie’s, and the first wedding ceremony in front of our doors in 2020. We were honored!”
Among the original flavors are rum raisin, butter pecan, and tutti frutti. Two interior Art Deco “sundaes” signs originated from the famed Horn & Hardart Automat chain. The scrumptious menu evolved, appealing to increasingly diverse tastes, but the originals, authenticity, and the magic touch remain consistent. “We make special flavors that have not been prepared in the past, such as pumpkin spice. We have been preparing it for a few years now, and our customers absolutely love it,” said Angelina. Vito continued, “In the summer, we prepare blueberry flavor and peach flavor, and people can’t wait to come late spring or early summer to get some. When those flavors are not available, patrons definitely become sad since they love them.”
Staff members and patrons alike become an extended family that are not only enticed by ice cream sundaes, but coffee, chocolate soda, and vanilla ice cream soda. Vito explained, “We added a hot chocolate menu, which we all absolutely love, and of course a classic vanilla hot fudge sundae is always great.” Angelina added, “For the afterhours, we all love to enjoy some great treats here, but my favorite would be the raspberry ice cream with marshmallow topping sundae. It takes me back to when Vito and I had our first date here. And of course, we cannot forget our shakes and molts! The banana split and banana royal are so decadent and scrumptious!”
“We want to keep preparing great and delicious homemade ice cream, toppings, and whipped cream,” said Vito. Every day flourishes into a wonderful celebration, “Eddie’s Sweet Shop style.” He continued, “We definitely looked forward to our 100th birthday in summer 2025, and this year was our 101st birthday, which was special and fun. We had many different milestones besides our family’s, and we are honored to have many patrons celebrate with their families here.” That includes proposals, engagements, birthday parties, weddings, retirement parties, gender reveal celebrations, first birthday celebrations. The first time a baby is eating dairy, Eddie’s Sweet Shop became the go-to spot. “We recently accommodated a very special customer who celebrated her 100th birthday, and we were very happy to celebrate her and with her,” said Angelina.

Holding up Monopoly Queens featuring Eddie’s Sweet Shop, Photo courtesy of the Citrano family.
Vito and Angelina gifted “Monopoly Queens Edition” to Senator Addabbo. Eddie’s Sweet Shop’s placement on the board in 2024 was a true honor, in which the couple continues to feel grateful for patrons who voted for their shop. “The Monopoly Queens game sales are great. Everybody has been enjoying it, and of course playing the game with their families, trying to buy Eddie’s up. We love hearing all their fun stories and viewing photos,” said Angelina.
Since early on, a promotion has been underway. “If you buy the Monopoly Queens board for $45 including tax at Eddie’s, you will receive a $20 gift certificate to use for ice cream on your next visit. People have been loving it and thanking us,” Vito. Additionally, considering that the Citrano family embraces a humanitarian spirit, they have been donating many to various schools and fundraisers, which is rewarding.
They shared part of Eddie’s Sweet Shop’s recipe for success to aspiring entrepreneurs. “We would tell anyone hoping to launch a mom and pop shop to dream big and aim for it, but have amazing products, which makes a huge difference.”
Vito and Angelina explained, “We love to see everyone enjoy their special and unique treat with quality ingredients at Eddie’s Sweet Shop. Some have been loyal patrons for years who take a break from their busy day. Families step inside to enjoy dessert, and a couple enjoys an ice cream date. We love it all.”
